SPEECH DELAY IN MULTILINGUAL FAMILY
13/06/2020 Views : 316
Ketut Santi Indriani
A child could
experience speech delay caused by physical or environmental factors
(Syamsuardi, 2015: 68). Physical health factor, such as abnormalities from
birth, can cause speech delay in a child. Asphyxia, seizures and oropharyngeal
deformities are examples of health factors which often result in the risk of speech
delay in children. In addition, environmental factors also affect the ability
of a child to speak. The immediate environment, the family, plays an important
role in a child's ability to speak. Parental education, kinship, stimulation
provided to children and family background are some of the things that affect a
child's ability to speak. (Sunderajan and Kanhere, 2019: 1643).
Talking about family
background, the parents’ background is very important to note because it is
related to the mother tongue or language used by parents. In a case of
multilingual family residing in Singapore, it was found that the only child in
the family experienced speech delay until the age of eight. Certainly, this would
be a concern for the parents, considering that a child should have started
talking at the age of 11 to 14 months. Other concern is that at the age of eight,
the child was study in a primary school. The speech delay could affect his
education and social life. In this case it was found that the father was French
and the mother was Indonesian. The language used by the father is English while
the mother uses Bahasa. The interesting thing that caused this family to become
a multilingual family was that the maid who worked in their home is Filipino and
communicate in Tagalog.
The child experienced
speech delay which was very likely caused by language confusion. Interestingly,
language confusion was not caused by the many input types of language he
received, but the inconsistency of language use. The inconsistency can be
described as follows. The father who daily used English to communicate often used
Bahasa when communicating with the child. Likewise, the mother who daily used
Bahasa often used English when communicating with the child. Because of the
limited skill to speak English, the house maid also often used Tagalog when
communicating with the child. This can cause confusion for the child that
encourages the emergence of speech delay.
This becomes interesting when both parents decided to consult with a child growth and development expert. The expert suggested that each family member should consistently use one language in communicating with the child. This aims to give the child a consistent pattern of communication within the family. Father must be consistent in using only English in communicating with child, mother must be consistent in using only Bahasa and the house maid must consistently use only Tagalog.
The result of the
application of the consistent use of language by each family member caused a
very significant change in the child's speaking ability. In less than 6 months,
the child could speak three languages fluently; English, Bahasa and Tagalog.
The most important thing that becomes the key to success in implementing this
language consistency is that the child can absorb the right information from
every language, in terms of pronunciation, intonation and language structure of
the native speaker. No less important in the consistency of language used is
that the child has a great opportunity to hear and speak using these three
languages (Byers-Heinlein, K. and Lew-Williams, 2013: 112).
-------------------------------
Byers-Heinlein,
K. and Lew-Williams, C. 2013. Bilingualism in the Early Years: What the Science
Says. LEARNing Landscapes Journal, Autumn
7(1): 95–112.
Sunderajan,
T. and Kanhere, S. V. 2019. Speech and language delay in children: Prevalence
and risk factors. Journal of Family
Medicine Primary Care, May; 8(5): 1642–1646.
Syamsuardi.
2015. Speech Delay and Its Affecting Factors (Case Study in a Child with
Initial Aq). Journal of Education and
Practice, 6 (32): 68-71.